Nov 24, 2008 milk tells harvey milk s story as one of a transformed life, a victory for individual freedom over state persecution, and a political and social cause. And they were vilified, at times even by their families, for being. Harvey milk civil rights academy is a small, public alternative elementary school located in the heart of the castro district. Navy during the korean war and was discharged in 1955 milk later said that he was dishonourably discharged due to his homosexuality, but. I first saw the film a couple of years after its 1984 release, when id never before heard the words gay and civil rights in the same sentence. This lucid, empathic 1984 documentary about the first openly gay elected official in california focusses on harvey milk as a grassroots politician who viewed gay rights. The times of harvey milk to receive cinema eye legacy award. Ironically, the same election that brought milk to the board of city supervisors of san francisco also elected the man who killed him, a. Milk tells harvey milks story as one of a transformed life, a victory for individual freedom over state persecution, and a political and social cause.
Social and political themes in the movie milk essay bartleby. The times of harvey milk, rob epsteins superb 1984 documentary, summons its emotionally shattering force from the rhyme of these lights. As a fan of gus van sants 2008 film milk, im pretty aware of harvey milk s life and influence. One of those interviewed in the movie said the jury would have found white guilty of murder if just the mayor had been shot and killed, but harveys sexual. Settling in the castro district, he opens a camera shop and helps transform the area into a mecca for gays and lesbians. May 05, 2010 the bullhorn used by harvey milk in his campaign for gay equality has become the focus of a dispute between its caretaker and a school named for mr.
The times of harvey milk is a 1984 documentary film directed by rob epstein it is about, yes, harvey milk 19301978. The times of harvey milk was met with strong praise from critics. The oscarwinning the times of harvey milk, directed by robert epstein and produced by richard schmiechen, was as groundbreaking. The times of harvey milk describes the lives and deaths of milk and mayor george moscone, who both were shot dead in 1978 by dan white, one of milks fellow supervisors. Jan 30, 2008 thousands of local volunteer extras perform a faux candlelight vigil down market street for harvey milk for a scene in the film, milk staring sean penn on saturday, february 9, 2008 in san.
Director rob epstein spoke later about why he chose the subject of milks life. A person worth documenting is harvey milk, the first openly gay elected official in the united states who fought for gay rights and inspired equality for the united states. The oscarwinning the times of harvey milk was as groundbreaking as its subject. The times of harvey milk, a documentary film based on the books material, won the 1984 academy award for documentary feature. Milk, a gay man and an activist for gay rights, was elected to the san francisco board of supervisors in 1977, becoming the first openly gay man elected to political office in san francisco and quite likely the first openly gay man elected to any political office anywhere in. The film was directed by rob epstein, produced by richard schmiechen, and narrated by harvey fierstein, with an original score by mark isham. Filmmaker robert epstein profiles the slain san francisco gayrights activist. In the conventional but moving oscarwinning documentary the times of harvey milk, which has just been released in a twodisc, 20thanniversary edition, milk s political acumen is illustrated partially through his relationship with a brusque union machinist who concedes that hed probably still be a reflexive homophobe if hed never met milk. The life and career of harvey milk have been the subjects of an opera, books, and films. In the chicago suntimes, roger ebert called it an enormously absorbing film, for the light it sheds on a decade in the life of a great american city and on the lives of milk and moscone, who made it a better, and certainly a more interesting, place to live. One of the first feature documentaries to address gay life in america, its a work of advocacy itself, bringing milks message of.
Ten years later, harvey milk, an opera cocommissioned by the houston grand opera, the new york city opera, and the san francisco opera, opened in houston. Global human rightslgbt civil rights speaker and advocate. Postscript containing interview clips not used in the film. The times of harvey milk 1984 full movie download full hd. Van sant was equivocal when i asked why he chose not to film the riots. He is the co founder and board president of the all volunteer harvey milk foundation. Mar 23, 2014 but when you see the documentary the times of harvey milk, the spellbinding nature of the narrative plays second fiddle to the rage, shock, despair, and, ultimately, hope it evokes. The bullhorn used by harvey milk in his campaign for gay equality has become the focus of a dispute between its caretaker and a school named for mr.
Rob ebsteins 1984 documentary about the life and assassination of californias first openly gay. This oscarwinning film uses original documentary material and archival footage to present both the story and message of harvey milks political career and assassination. There is a remarkable shot near the end, showing a candlelight march reaching as far as the eyes can see. This is an enormously absorbing film, for the light it sheds on a decade in the life of a great american city and on the lives of milk and moscone, who made it a better, and certainly a more. Harvey milk fought for gay rights in the mid to late 70s. The times of harvey milk is a 1984 american documentary film that premiered at the telluride film festival, the new york film festival, and then on november 1, 1984 at the castro theatre in san francisco.
Oct 15, 2008 milk was previously the subject of the academy awardwinning documentary feature the times of harvey milk, but milk filmed on location in san francisco is the first nondocumentary feature to. The times of harvey milk describes the lives and deaths of milk and mayor george moscone, who both were shot dead in 1978 by dan white, one of milk s fellow supervisors. Stuart milk is an international human rights activist, lgbt rights speaker, government relations consultant, and youth advocate. Harvey milk american politician and activist britannica. The asheville film society will screen the times of harvey milk tuesday, june 8, at 8 p. Harvey milk biography life, family, story, death, history. Milks bullhorn, a gay unifier, now divides the new york times. Stuart milk, founder and president harvey milk foundation. The times of harvey milk describe the lives of milk and mayor george moscone, who was also murdered along with milk by dan white in november of 1978. New program about the times of harvey milk and gus van sants milk, featuring epstein, van sant, actor james franco, and milk friends cleve jones, anne kronenberg, and nicoletta.
I wasnt aware that milk is pretty much a film adaptation of the times of harvey milk. With a blend of archive footage and interviews, this documentary works at lightning speed pace within the 84 minutes for direct information and maximum emotional. Rent the times of harvey milk 1984 on dvd and bluray netflix. After graduating from the new york state college for teachers in albany 1951, milk served in the u. One of the first feature documentaries to address gay life in america, its a work of advocacy itself, bringing milks message of hope and equality to a wider audience. The times of harvey milk 1984 the criterion collection. Harvey milk, american politician and gayrights activist. This documentary examines the political life of the selfproclaimed mayor of castro street, n. In 1972, harvey milk sean penn and his thenlover scott smith leave new york for san francisco, with milk determined to accomplish something meaningful in his life.
Rare collection of audio and video recordings of harvey milk. Oct 27, 1984 the times of harvey milk was shown as part of the 1984 new york film festival. The oscarwinning the times of harvey milk, directed by robert epstein and produced by richard schmiechen, was as groundbreaking as its subject. Directed by gus van sant and written by dustin lance black, the film stars sean penn as milk. Director rob epstein spoke later about why he chose the subject of milk s life. It also describes the political and social climate in san francisco, which during the 1960s and 1970s began to attract growing numbers of gays because of its traditionally. It also describes the political and social climate in san francisco, which had been rising during the cultural revolution of the 1960s and where a growing number of gay men began to move. The film was directed by rob epstein, produced by richard schmiechen, and narrated by harvey fierstein, with an original score by mark isham in 2012, this film was deemed culturally.
But when you see the documentary the times of harvey milk, the spellbinding nature of the narrative plays second fiddle to the rage, shock, despair, and, ultimately, hope it evokes. These include the shiltss biography, the mayor of castro street 1982. A documentary of the successful career and assassination of. Winner of an academy award for best documentary feature, the times of harvey milk was released. A documentary of the successful career and assassination of san franciscos first elected gay city supervisor. One of those interviewed in the movie said the jury would have found white guilty of murder if just the mayor had been shot and killed, but harvey s sexual orientation gave them an out for a lesser charge. In the conventional but moving oscarwinning documentary the times of harvey milk, which has just been released in a twodisc, 20thanniversary edition, milks political acumen is illustrated partially through his relationship with a brusque union machinist who concedes that hed probably still be a reflexive homophobe if hed never met milk. Mar 22, 2011 the times of harvey milk enacts the emotional labor of melodrama in its documentary structures, forestalling closure, visiting and revisiting key points, locating wisdom in a chorus of voices, even orchestrating its massive street scenes through editing as masterfully as if theyd been staged by some brilliant choreographer up above, wings. The film considers milks accomplishments and his exceptional popularity. A true twentiethcentury trailblazer, harvey milk was an outspoken human rights activist and one of the first openly gay u. A devastatingly skillful and emotionally compelling documentary, the times of harvey milk charts the political rise and brutal slaying of the first openly gay city official in the united state, harvey milk.
It was a film of its time, when gays could not be open and visible and were ostracized by the mainstream society, including losing their jobs if they were discovered to be homosexual or lesbian. Milk was murdered in november 1978 by a former colleague, dan white. The times of harvey milk was shown as part of the 1984 new york film festival. In the chicago sun times, roger ebert called it an enormously absorbing film, for the light it sheds on a decade in the life of a great american city and on the lives of milk and moscone, who made it a better, and certainly a more interesting, place to live. The times of harvey milk is a flawless documentary about on e of the most iconic civil rights activists of the 20th century. With moving performance footage and appearances by collaborators including dolly parton, emmylou harris, bonnie raitt, and jackson browne, this documentary by rob epstein and jeffrey friedman the times of harvey milk celebrates an artist whose desire to share the music she loved made generations of fans fall in love with herand the sound.
In 1977 he becomes the nations first openly gay man elected to a notable public office when he wins a seat. The times of harvey milk enacts the emotional labor of melodrama in its documentary structures, forestalling closure, visiting and revisiting key points, locating wisdom in a chorus of voices, even orchestrating its massive street scenes through editing as masterfully as if theyd been staged by some brilliant choreographer up above, wings. The times of harvey milk by robert epstein harvey milk. The life and times of harvey milk documentary free online. A 1984 academy award winner for best documentary feature, the times of harvey milk is a riveting account of politician harvey milks rise to power in san francisco and his fight for gay rights. At the time, for those of us who lived in san francisco, it felt like it was life changing, that all the eyes of the world were upon us. With harvey fierstein, harvey milk, anne kronenberg, tory hartmann. More than three decades later, the times of harvey milk is still earning accolades. Jun 02, 2010 the asheville film society will screen the times of harvey milk tuesday, june 8, at 8 p. Hosted by xpress movie critics ken hanke and justin souther. Rent the times of harvey milk 1984 starring harvey fierstein on dvd and bluray. In 1985 the film the times of harvey milk won the academy award for best documentary. Milk is a 2008 american biographical film based on the life of gay rights activist and politician harvey milk, who was the first openly gay person to be elected to public office in california, as a member of the san francisco board of supervisors.
Directed by gus van sant and written by dustin lance black, the film stars sean penn as milk and. There are two mainly renowned films about harvey milk, which will be compared for this essay. Harvey bernard milk was born on may 22, 1930, in woodmere, new york. Documents the political career of harvey milk, san franciscos first openly gay supervisor, his rise from a neighborhood activist to a symbol of gay political achievement, through to his assassination in november 1978 at san franciscos city hall, and the dan white trial and aftermath.
Dec 14, 2016 more than three decades later, the times of harvey milk is still earning accolades. The times of harvey milk 1984 by rob epstein and milk 2008 by gus van sant. Thousands of local volunteer extras perform a faux candlelight vigil down market street for harvey milk for a scene in the film, milk staring sean penn on saturday, february 9, 2008 in san. The times of harvey milk is an interesting and at moments inspiring documentary about a notorious double killing that took place in san franciscos city hall in 1978.
260 1078 1056 1370 1417 1528 255 415 1514 437 382 473 158 131 1548 27 488 1187 213 1298 446 1053 1562 1035 1481 132 131 706 265 865 747 1552 232 1197 1143 148 393 314 358 1229 553